Between Grain-Fed Vs Grass-Fed Meat: How Do They Differ? | Ryan's Grocery (2024)

Shopping for red meat, whether through an online grocery store or at a supermarket, you may have come across the labels ‘grain-fed’ and ‘grass-fed’. These labels describe the type of food consumed by the cattle, typically applicable to beef and lamb.

Simply put, grain-fed means the animal feed is dominated by grains such as corn, barley, and soy while grass-fed implies that the cattle are fed with mostly grass. However, there are more than just diet differences you should know about to make the best buying decision out of grain-fed vs grass-fed.

This will help you find the type of red meat that meets your preferences perfectly, making the dining experience more enjoyable for you and your family.

So keep on reading and discover the differences between these types of meat.

The Differences Between Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed

What is Grain-Fed?

Grain-fed means that the animals’ diets involve eating grains like corn, soy, and barley. Grain is high in starch, which is a good source of dietary energy and helps to speed up their growth.

Besides being fed with a grain-rich diet, grain-fed animals are also typically kept in confined areas with feedlots. This is done as the whole process is focused on resulting in a controlled meat quality that meets certain standards.

Pros and Cons of Grain Fed Meat

Pros:

• Juicy meat profile
• Higher marbling
• Widely available in the market

Cons:

• Higher in calories
• May not be suitable for those who prefer leaner meat
• Less healthy fats

What is Grass-Fed?

Grass-fed implies that the meat product is sourced from animals that mostly eat grass. The animals are also raised in a pasture, where they can roam freely and consume a variety of grasses before being transported to a slaughterhouse.

Additionally, grass-fed animals are never fed grains and are not confined to a feedlot. This lifestyle results in leaner meat with higher muscle mass, as the cattle have access to grazing areas that allow for natural feeding and physical movement.

Pros and Cons of Grass-Fed Meat

Pros:

• Leaner meat profile
• Higher in healthy fats
• Lower in calories

Cons:

• Texture can be chewy
• Less marbling
• Fewer options in the market

Grain-Fed and Grass-Fed Meat: Where Are They Sourced From?

Grain-fed and grass-fed meat are sourced differently. Grass-fed meat is usually imported from countries where grass-fed farms are more popular such as Australia and Scotland.

On the other hand, grain-fed meat can both be imported or sourced domestically from local farms. This is because grain-fed farms require less land, allowing for faster and more efficient finishing of cattle for slaughter.

However, high-quality grain-fed meat is often imported from overseas farms that employ organic and innovative farming practices. This ensures that the meat produced meets the standard of premium grain-fed meat, featuring high marbling on the surface.

In terms of availability, grain-fed meat is more widely accessible than grass-fed meat. Grass-fed meat is typically only found in select supermarkets with more limited options, whereas grain-fed meat is easily accessible with a broader selection.

Nutritional Compositions Between Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed Meat

Since there are diet differences between grain-fed and grass-fed cattle, this will also result in different meat nutritional compositions. Simply saying, grass-fed meat has a leaner profile than grain-fed meat. But how about the vitamins and minerals? We’ll explain below:

Grain-Fed Beef vs Grass-Fed Beef

When it comes to grain-fed beef vs grass-fed beef nutritional compositions, both similarly contain essential vitamins like Vitamin B12, B3, and B6 along with iron, selenium, and zinc.

However, grass-fed beef has been proven to contain higher levels of certain nutrients such as:

• Vitamin A: Grass is rich in carotenoids, such as beta-carotene, which is a precursor to Vitamin A. These carotenoids are stored in the cow’s fat tissues, leading to higher Vitamin A levels in grass-fed beef.
• Vitamin E: Grass also contains richer amounts of antioxidants, including Vitamin E. These antioxidants are consumed by the cow, resulting in beef with higher levels of Vitamin E.

Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed Lamb

Lamb is favoured for its rich, distinctive taste that is best described as earthy. It also contains rich nutrients like protein, fats, Vitamin B12, and zinc. However, the nutrient content can vary depending on whether the lamb is grass-fed or grain-fed.

Meat sourced from lambs that roam freely and primarily eat grass tends to have higher protein and lower fat content. This is because, as the lambs move freely, it promotes greater muscle mass and leaner body fat.

On the contrary, grain-fed lambs mostly have higher levels of fat. This is essential to result in juicy and tender lamb meat.

Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed Meat: The Flavour Profile

Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed Beef Flavour

Aside from the beef cuts, the cow’s diet can also influence beef flavour. There are several differences between grain-fed vs grass-fed meat profiles, including:

• Texture: When it comes to texture, grain-fed beef is more tender than grass-fed beef due to the animals’ diet and living conditions. This makes grain-fed beef a more suitable option if you fancy naturally tender steaks and vice versa.

• Fat content: Grass-fed beef has lower fat content, contributing to its leaner profile. In contrast, grain-fed has higher fat, which enhances its tenderness and succulence.

• Marbling: Higher fat content in grain-fed beef contributes to its greater marbling compared to grass-fed beef. Marbling is one of the key factors that determine meat grade, as it melts during the cooking process, adding to the steak’s tenderness.

Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed Lamb Flavour

Diet type apparently also affects how lamb meat tastes. Here are the differences between grain-fed and grass-fed meat flavour profiles:

• Texture: Grass-fed and grain-fed lamb present different texture profiles—with grain-fed typically offering greater tenderness. But the age of the lamb itself is also important. The younger the lamb, the more tender the meat.

• Fat content: Similar to beef, the fat content in lamb is also determined by the animal’s diet. Grass-fed lamb has a lower fat content compared to grain-fed lamb, resulting in a leaner steak.

• Marbling: Grain-fed lamb, which has higher fat content, similarly presents more marbling. These extra white intramuscular fats will melt during the cooking process, providing a self-marinating effect that enhances tenderness and juiciness.

Environmental Impact of Grain-Fed and Grass-Fed Meat

Farming is one of the activities that contribute to climate change. Animal waste, fertilisers used for animal feed, and land use for livestock grazing are the factors driving this environmental impact.

Thus, determining the environmental impact of grain-fed vs grass-fed meat is complex and uncertain. Both methods have advantages and disadvantages in terms of their effects on the climate.

For example, grain-fed farms focus on effective land use, considering that cattle are kept in confined areas with feedlots. This means that the amount of trees cut down for farming is not as significant compared to the farming method using a grass-fed diet.

Although grain-fed farms emphasise effective land use, they involve the use of chemicals to cultivate grains that serve as animal feed. The chemicals used are usually pesticides and fertilisers, both contribute to gas emissions.

On the other hand, grass-fed farms will need a wide land used for grazing. Wide land use means cutting down trees abundantly to turn them into farms. Meanwhile, trees are important for absorbing carbon, and their decrease can have an impact on the environment.

However, grass-fed cattle rely mainly on wild vegetation. This means grass-fed farms can reduce the use of fertilisers and pesticides, two chemicals that are beneficial to cultivating grains yet contribute to gas emissions.

Introducing Organic Carbon Neutral Farms

Conventional farming practices, both grain-fed and grass-fed, similarly produce gas emissions. However, as modern farming continues to evolve, organic carbon-neutral farms are on the rise.

Organic carbon-neutral farms prioritise sustainability and ethical farming. Such farms raise livestock in certified organic land and pasture. There are no chemicals, pesticides, and fertilisers used, including in the animal feed.

The cattle are also fed with 100% organic feed, containing no growth hormones, antibiotics, preservatives, and other synthetic chemicals.

There is a saying, “You are what you eat,” and this applies to what the animals you eat have consumed as well. By avoiding chemicals and synthetic additives in organic carbon-neutral beef and lamb, you are opting for healthier meat.

Between Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed: Which is Healthier?

While grass-fed meat is leaner and contains more healthy fats such as omega-3, unsaturated fats, and conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), eating grain-fed meat is equally healthy.

Meat offers numerous health benefits, as it’s rich in protein, essential vitamins, and minerals. Eating it provides you with energy, supports muscle growth, and helps in maintaining a healthy and balanced diet.

You can freely choose certain cuts that meet your preferences (e.g., sirloin for a leaner texture and ribeye for a fattier steak). Whether you prefer to grill or roast your meat, you’ll still get the health benefits from it, making grain-fed vs grass-fed choices less important.

Besides, meat can be easily combined with a plant-based diet. You can serve it with salad, roasted veggies, or mashed potato for extra nutritious home-cooked dishes.

Price Comparisons Between Grain-Fed vs Grass-Fed Meat

Conventionally, one might expect grain-fed meat to be more affordable than grass-fed meat due to its greater accessibility. However, this isn’t always the case. Grain-fed meat can sometimes be more expensive than grass-fed meat.

The higher cost of grain-fed meat is due to the quality of production. Despite its availability, grain-fed cattle are often raised with specific methods and diets.

For instance, in the case of 200-day grain-fed black Angus beef, cattle are initially raised on pastures, consuming mainly grass. They are then moved to feedlots, where they are fed with mostly grains for 200 days before being sent to the slaughterhouse.

This process results in higher-quality meat, which may contribute to its increased prices. Therefore, when comparing the prices of grain-fed and grass-fed meat, it’s important to consider the meat quality, as there is no standard measure

Whether You Prefer Grain-Fed or Grass-Fed Meat, The Quality Comes From Where You Shop For it

When choosing between grain-fed and grass-fed meat, it’s important to know that the quality is almost identical. Grass-fed meat tends to be leaner and higher in healthy fats, but both types of meat provide essential protein, vitamins, and minerals to support your health.

What truly matters in determining the meat quality is where you shop for it. Selecting a reputable store with fresh butchery options ensures you get the best beef or lamb, guaranteed to meet your preferences for delicious home-cooked dishes.

This is where our grocery store excels. At Ryan’s Grocery, we offer a wide variety of beef and lamb, both grain-fed and grass-fed, to meet your needs.

Explore our promotional deals and shop online for convenience. We’ll also deliver your items right to your doorstep, ensuring your shopping experience is as easy as a few taps.

FAQ